QCM Review Results

One of the reasons that Quality Control Material (QCM) providers may elect to have an independent review of their system of quality control for the development and maintenance of the QCM they have developed, and of the materials themselves, is to provide more cost-effective peer reviews for firms that use such QCM. In addition, the AICPA Standards for Performing and Reporting on Peer Reviews (Standards) and related Interpretations require peer reviewers to evaluate the firm’s use of QCM as a part of its system of quality control, and to consider the impact of that evaluation on the risk assessment. QCM Review reports and related documents are important tools in this evaluation process.

The Standards require that providers allow the AICPA and National PRC to disclose certain QCM information to make it easily accessible to peer reviewers. Therefore, the most recently accepted QCM review reports and related acceptance letters are available via this webpage.

Note that:

  • Scope:
    • Some providers will have multiple QCM review reports posted as different materials/guides are covered by different reports (for instance, the provider may rotate what QCM are covered in each year’s QCM review).
    • Some providers provide QCM on multiple platforms with varying functionality.  Carefully consider what QCM is identified in the QCM review report.
  • Report Presentation:
    • The number of documents posted will vary based upon the results of the peer review and the report presentation.
    • Documents will remain posted for the QCM review's effective dates in the last three years, or until the provider's subsequent QCM review has been completed and accepted, whichever period is longer. 
  • QCM Examinations:  Some QCM providers are obtaining a new type of assurance on their QCM - an examination under the Statements on Standards for Attestation Engagements (SSAEs) (QCM Examination).   We expect that over time, QCM Examinations will replace the QCM Reviews performed under AICPA Peer Review Program Standards that peer reviewers are more familiar with.  This also represents a shift away from the QCM engagement being subject to AICPA oversight and acceptance by the National Peer Review Committee.  For more information, see the October 2019 Reviewers Alert.

Most Recent QCM Review Results

If you need to obtain the QCM review results for providers that are not posted below, or for QCM examination results, please contact the provider directly.

Searchable PDF Tool Summarizing QCM Review Results

BDO USA, LLP

Caseware International

CCH, a Wolters Kluwer business (Knowledge-Based QCM)

Thomson Reuters Practitioner's Publishing Company (PPC)

Wiley Advantage Audit