Expert Panel - Stockbrokerage and Investment Banking 

About the Expert Panel
The Stockbrokerage and Investment Banking Expert Panel serves the needs of AICPA members on financial and business reporting and audit and attest matters. The expert panel protects the public interest by bringing together knowledgeable parties in the stockbrokerage and investment banking industry to deliberate and come to agreement on key stockbrokerage and investment banking issues.
Industry News and Resources

Expert Panel Projects

  • The AICPA staff has compiled a summary of audit, attestation and independence standards applicable to AICPA members performing audit and attestation engagements for certain SEC and/or CFTC-registered entities
  • Illustrative examples of compliance report and exemption report required by the SEC Rule 17a-5.
  • The Center for Audit Quality (CAQ) and the AICPA have issued a joint member Independence Alert that provides audit firms with an overview of SEC and PCAOB independence rules applicable to financial statement audit and attestation engagements for the following non-issuers:
    • Non-issuer broker-dealers that are registered with the SEC as a broker or dealer; and
    • Where the engagement(s) is subject to the requirements of Custody Rule, SEC-registered and state registered investment advisers, related party custodians, or private funds (e.g., pooled investment vehicles).
  • Members of the Expert Panel presented a live webinar “Broker-Dealer Update”, covering final amendments to SEC Rules 17a-5 and 17a-11 and new PCAOB attestation and auditing supplemental information standards for broker-dealer audits. Presentation slides are available.
  • The Center for Audit Quality (CAQ) and the American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) have jointly issued a Member Alert outlining regulatory changes that are applicable to audits and attestation engagements of Brokers and Dealers (BDs) and Futures Commission Merchants (FCMs), including those entities that are dual-registered.
  • The Panel has developed an example of an illustrative independent accountants' report on applying agreed-upon procedures related to the entity's claim for exclusion from membership in SIPC (Form SIPC-3), which is currently being reviewed by the specified parties. Once all parties have agreed, an illustrative example of such report will be posted here.

Securities and Exchange Commission

  • The SEC staff has issued a no-action letter that will permit broker-dealers and OTC derivative dealers to electronically file with the SEC the required annual and supplemental reports under SEA Rules 17a-5 and 17a-12, respectively, through the Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis and Retrieval system (EDGAR), in lieu of filing the reports in paper form.
  • The SEC Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations announced its 2016 examination priorities for investment advisers and investment companies, broker-dealers, and transfer agents.
  • The staff of the SEC Division of Trading and Markets recently issued staff guidance (in the form of FAQs). To read FAQs about the amendments to Rule 17a-5 and Form Custody, click here. For FAQs concerning certain broker-dealer financial responsibility rules, click here. Other FAQs published by the staff of the SEC Division of Trading and Markets are available here.
  • In July 2013, the SEC issued two final rules that affect broker-dealers registered with the SEC and their auditors. One rule adopts amendments that would increase protections for investors whose cash and securities are held by broker-dealers registered with the SEC. These amendments to SEC Rule 17a-5 require, in part, that the audits of broker-dealers' financial statements and supplemental information, as well as the auditor's examination of the compliance report or the auditor's review of the examination report, be conducted in accordance with PCAOB standards for fiscal years ending on or after June 1, 2014.

Public Company Accounting Oversight Board

  • PCAOB First Staff Inspection Brief - Information about 2016 Inspections of Auditors of Brokers and Dealers
  • Fifth annual report on the Progress of the Interim Inspection Program Related to Audits of Brokers and Dealers was released on August 18, 2016. The report covers inspections conducted in 2015, the first inspection year in which audits of SEC-registered broker-dealers have been performed under the PCAOB standards. This report cites high levels of audit deficiencies, similar to prior year’s inspection results. Independence continues to be a focus area. The report also states that the PCAOB staff is working to develop a rule proposal for the Board to consider during 2016 to establish a permanent inspection program, which will address, among other matters, whether to exempt any category of registered public accounting firm. Under the interim inspection program adopted in 2011, the PCAOB inspects audit engagements of all types of SEC-registered broker-dealers.
  • The PCAOB announced the dates for 2016 forums on auditing smaller broker-dealers. The SEC staff's recent presentation at the recent forum is available here.
  • PCAOB Reports Deficiencies in Broker-Dealer Audits under PCAOB Standards
  • Slides from recent PCAOB webinars that may be of interest to broker-dealers and their auditors are available:
  • Until the PCAOB announces the scope of their permanent inspection program, audits of broker-dealers will be subject to both PCAOB inspection and AICPA peer review. Peer reviewers are regularly identifying audits where the firm failed to comply with SEC independence rules by preparing the firm’s financial statements, which is consistent with the PCAOB interim inspection program findings. Read more on this topic and other peer review implications for broker dealer engagements.
  • On June 26, 2014, the PCAOB released staff guidance for auditors of SEC-registered brokers and dealers.
  • In October 2013, the PCAOB adopted two attestation standards pertaining to audits of brokers and dealers and an auditing standard, which is applicable when auditors are engaged to perform audit procedures and report on supplemental information that broker-dealers and others file with the SEC. These standards are effective for fiscal years ending on or after June 1, 2014.
U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
  • In November 2013, the CFTC approved a final rule on enhancing customer protections, which, in part, will require audits of futures commission merchants (FCMs) to be performed in accordance with PCAOB standards by a PCAOB-registered firm that “must have undergone a PCAOB inspection”. Find out more.

Past Meeting Highlights

June 1, 2016

March 2, 2016


December 2, 2015

September 2, 2015

June 2, 2015

March 4, 2015

2014 and Prior

Archived Meeting Highlights

Members of the Expert Panel

Paul Lameo, Chair PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Jeffrey Alfano, Oppenheimer & Co

David Bonnar, Morgan Stanley

Karen L. Dealey, Jefferies LLC

Christopher Donovan, Deloitte & Touche LLP

Michael Fehrman, Deutsche Bank

Nancy Grimaldi, EisnerAmper LLP

Paul Nockels, RSM US LLP

Daniel Palomaki, Citigroup

Mark Ramler, Grant Thornton LLP

Karl Ruhry, KPMG LLP

Stephen A. Zammitti, Ernst & Young LLP

Learn more about the expert panel members by reading their biographies.

Staff Contacts

Irina Portnoy, Senior Technical Manager

Expert Panel Recommended Guidance


CPE and Conferences


Copyright © 2006-2016 American Institute of CPAs.