o
be successful financial planners and investment
advisers, CPAs must keep up with a wide range of
changes in investment products, technology,
economic conditions and client management
techniques. While the body of required knowledge
may at times seem overwhelming, much of it is in
fact just common sense. Here are some of the
hot buttons CPAs should take into
account as they seek to develop and grow their
financial planning practices.
| FAILURE TO CONTROL
EMOTIONS |
Fear and greed are the two things that
routinely guide peoples attitudes toward
money and investments. While a certain amount of
these is healthy, too much of either can
overpower an individuals judgment. CPAs
need to help clients reduce fear so they can move
forward and help them keep greed in check so they
dont do anything foolish. Excessive stock
market volatility and shattered trust in
white-collar leadership have left
clients fearful their survival is
threatened. How fear operates varies within each
individualsome people manage it creatively,
others wreak havoc on themselves and those around
them.
Fear about money is a big deal
because of the attachments we have to it. We
often give money too much power in our
livesweakening ourselves in the process.
Markets have no power to hurt or help
anyonethey function impersonally and
equally for all. Its how we interact with a
market that has the potential to cause problems.
Hype, greed and panic have always been the
enemies of investment success. But if you, as a
planner, are able to keep a cool head on behalf
of your clients, you can do something
tremendously valuable: create a safer, saner
investment route to guide them through an
unfolding economy. Planners can refuse to allow
clients to be taken in by hype, keep them from
being too greedy or stop them from giving in to
panic. CPAs must help clients articulate their
goalsbecause goals are the fuel that move
client investments. Failure to set goals results
in an inability to control fear and greed and has
the potential to overcome even the soundest
investment plan in the strongest financial
market.
How can CPAs help clients
control greed and not panic? The best way is to
advise them to continue following the recommended
asset allocationeven during periods such as
the boom of the 1990s or the more recent market
downturn. Advise them to resist the temptation to
jump to a hot hedge fund or shift money into
fixed income investments. Abandoning a well
thought out strategy to reap windfall profits or
sell into a falling market is the quickest way
for clients to undo the benefits of a
comprehensive investment strategy and miss out on
future opportunities.
| AGGREGATION: A NEW
WEALTH MANAGEMENT TOOL? |
Are you using account aggregation? Have
you heard of it but believe it to be another
dot-com dream that will go bust? A few years ago
some financial advisers viewed it as a cool new
Internet tool, but in 2003 it still has few uses.
In the first three months of last year just 1% of
U.S. online households used such a service
according to Forrester Research.
Account aggregation lets you
collect all kinds of information on one Web page.
It lets you keep track of information as diverse
as bank and credit-card balances, the value of
investments, 401(k) accounts and frequent-flier
miles without having to jump from site to site.
The data are collected and displayed in a format
you can use. Many banks offer aggregation on
their Web sites. If your bank or credit union
doesnt have a Web site, you can sign up
directly for My Yodlee (www.yodlee.com), a company that provides aggregation
technology to most banks.
Aggregation for financial
planning is in its early stages and will likely
include a range of products. Clients might have
insurance, annuities, ordinary equities, mutual
funds, bonds and multicurrency ADRs. To handle
this diversity of products, CPAs will need a full
range of flexibility.
ByAllAccounts (www.byallaccounts.com) a leader in the field, is aiming its
services at financial planners. State Street, the
giant global securities custodian, provides a
robust utility tool and infrastructure that
combines securities processing, settlement, trust
accounting, performance reporting and
private-labels the entire service with the
CPA/investment advisers firm name. The
result is a middle office and a back office in a
box that includes ByAllAccounts and an integrated
asset-servicing platform for securities brokerage
and asset management services.
WealthTouch (www.wealthtouch.com) also uses ByAllAccounts. It serves
firms that manage the financial affairs of
high-net-worth individuals with complex
portfolios and accounts in a variety of financial
institutions, providing specialized accounting
and investment tracking along with proprietary
online reporting designed specifically for
wealthy clients. These services include
investment reporting, data aggregation, account
reconciliation, expense management and tax
compliance.
1st Global, a broker-dealer for
CPAs, has two platforms using an online
application from ByAllAccountsone for
financial advisers and one for clients.
WebPortfolio automatically aggregates account
information from approximately 900 different
financial institutions, including brokerage
firms, banks, trust companies, mutual fund
families and insurance companies, to create a
comprehensive snapshot of a
clients total wealth. CPA advisers can use
the information to assess risk and return,
analyze appropriate asset allocations and track a
clients financial goals.
But just listing a
clients financial information all in one
place isnt enough. The client will need
planning help and advisory services to develop a
financial plan and an asset-allocation model. In
the future, wealth management must combine
aggregation with advice, allowing CPA advisers to
use applications such as Financial Profiles,
DirectAdvice, Financial Engines or NetDecide to
offer financial planning and investment counsel.
These products include a comprehensive suite of
investment and planning tools and can provide a
seamless link to client accounts managed by the
adviser and by others. The end result is
increased client satisfaction and retention and
an opportunity to capture assets now managed
elsewhere.
What does the future hold for
aggregation? Given how slowly the concept is
catching on with both consumers and the financial
community, its not surprising many
observers predict it will fail. If the service
manages to hang on, CPAs should look carefully
before recommending clients use an aggregator to
track their financial affairs. In the next phase
of its development, as this technology becomes
part of a comprehensive wealth management
platform, some CPA firms will embrace it and use
it to the dual advantage of themselves and their
clients.
| BONDS: THE CLASSIC
COUNTERBALANCE |
Most professional advisers recommend
clients diversify by owning some fixed-income
investments. Bonds typically fluctuate in value
less, and at different times, from stocks. There
are essentially two ways to make money from
bonds: (1) capital gains, achieved by selling a
bond for more than it cost and (2) periodic
interest payments. Like common stocks, bonds
fluctuate in market value and, if sold before
maturity, may produce a gain or a loss.
The primary reasons to invest
in bonds are to add stability to a portfolio and
receive dependable income. For stability,
short-term, high-quality bonds work best. Prices
dont fluctuate as much because investors
dont have to wait as long to get their
principal back. And high-quality bonds lessen the
risk of not getting interest payments on time or
principal back at maturity. For maximum stability
and safety, many advisers recommend five-year (or
shorter) U.S. Treasury securities held until
maturity.
When held to maturity,
high-quality bonds (the term refers to the
issuers creditworthiness) are generally
considered conservative investments. But bonds
are not without risk. With interest rates at
40-year lows, any uptick in rates likely will
lead to lower bond prices (bond prices move in
the opposite direction of interest rates). Risk
arises when a fixed-income investment is sold
before maturity. However, it also can work to an
investors advantage. If a client sells a
fixed-income investment before its maturity date
and interest rates have fallen since the original
purchase, he or she may receive more than the
original principal.
Selecting
individual bonds. How do CPAs
choose from myriad government or corporate bonds?
Surprisingly, its not difficult. Its
possible to achieve consistent above-average
performance in all types of markets with a
passive portfolio-management strategy called the
laddered or staggered
maturity approach.
Laddering means spacing
maturities, for example by investing 10% of the
portfolio at a time so each segment matures
annually for 10 years. To understand how
laddering works, consider a client with $200,000
to invest in bonds. He or she invests equal
dollar amounts at regular intervals along the
yield curve. For example, the client could
purchase ten bonds each with a $20,000 face
value, one bond maturing annually for 10
consecutive years. When the first bond matures,
the proceeds are reinvested in a new 10-year bond
and so on.
Depending on the circumstances,
ladders may be of different durationsof
longer or shorter maturities. The average
maturity of the portfolio described above is six
years. More important, it spans approximately two
business cycles. As time passes and the first
bond matures, the client can invest in another
10-year bond and continue this cycle as long as
he or she wants to hold domestic fixed income
bonds. This approach means the investor is never
concentrated in one maturity.
Using a bond fund. These
can be even trickier than bonds themselves
becausecontrary to what the name
impliesthey really arent fixed-income
investments. Even when a mutual funds
portfolio is composed entirely of bonds, the fund
itself has neither a fixed yield nor a
contractual obligation to give investors back
their principal at some later maturity
datethe two key characteristics of
individual bonds.
In addition, because fund
managers constantly trade their positions, the
risk-return profile of a bond fund is continually
changing: Unlike an individual bond, whose risk
level declines the longer an investor holds it, a
fund can increase or decrease its risk exposure
at the managers whim. In this way a bond
fund is closer in character to stocks or stock
funds than to individual bonds.
Does that mean fixed-income
investors should avoid bond funds? Not
necessarily. Bond funds may be appropriate for
clients who know exactly why they are investing
and what they expect to get. Thats why
before a client invests in a fund it makes sense
for his or her CPA to ask these questions:
How much do you want to
invest? If the client has less than
$100,000, and seeks tax-free income, his or her
best choice is probably a municipal bond fund. A
diversified portfolio of individual municipal
bonds requires at least $100,000. (Most are sold
in lots of $25,000.) Bond funds require a much
lower minimum investment: Top-quality municipal
bond funds at Vanguard, for example, require only
$3,000; American Centurys Benham funds
$2,500 to $5,000, depending on the fund; and
Scudder $2,500.
What kinds of bonds? If
the answer is corporate bonds, the best option is
probably a bond fund. Corporate bonds usually
require a large stake and have other drawbacks
for the average investor: high transaction costs,
no shelter from taxes and the risk the issuer
will call the best bonds, ending the income
stream. Government agency mortgage bonds are also
difficult to buy; many investors have learned the
hard way that, while mortgage funds may offer
somewhat higher yields than Treasuries, the extra
income can come at a cost down the road with an
increased risk of default and mortgage
prepayments as rates fall.
What price convenience?
Some income-oriented investors have been
enticed into funds merely for the sake of
convenience because many bond funds pay out
income monthly, rather than annually or
semiannually, making cash management easier. In
the long run, however, for most investors the
regular cash flow is worth neither the added risk
of bond funds nor the costs.
Exchange-traded
funds (ETFs). Clients also can now
invest in fixed-income iShares. This new
generation of ETFs is a bond portfolio that
investors can buy and sell throughout the trading
day like shares of stock. Barclays Global
Investors partnered with Lehman Brothers and
Goldman Sachs to introduce four new ETFs, all
traded on the American Stock Exchange. Like
traditional open-ended mutual funds, these
bond-based ETFs enable investors to purchase a
basket of bonds with one simple transaction.
Unlike bond funds, however, bond ETFs may be
traded throughout the day at market price. In
addition, whereas mutual funds are required to
disclose their holdings semiannually, iShares
holdings are available daily.
| MODERN PORTFOLIO
THEORY TURNS 50 |
In the late 1990s investors went too far
with the belief that only stocks could provide a
retirement nest egg. That illusion prompted them
to fill their 401(k)s with 100% stocks. That
strategy was never justified because of exactly
what weve seen over the past few years.
Things can go wrong. Thats why
clients portfolios need to be diversified.
Period. With the need for diversification and
asset allocation finally clear, clients who
didnt want to hear about modern portfolio
theory (MPT)much less practice it during
the bull marketare now listening.
Harry Markowitz and Merton
Miller developed MPT in 1952 and William Sharpe
expanded on it later; the three won the 1990
Nobel Prize for Economics for their contribution
to investment methodology. Now 50 years after its
birth, we enter the age of MPT.
Market snapshot. At
the time of this writing, stocks remain mired in
the third year of a bear market. As of November
2002 all of the major equity market indices are
in negative territory. The current investment
environment remains difficult, with factors
extraneous to the market and the economy playing
a larger role in influencing investor psychology
than at any point in the past two decades.
Investors have been severely
shaken by each revelation of corporate greed.
Ideally, these disclosures should compel
institutional shareholders to be more active in
setting minimum standards for corporate
governance, encouraging boards to hold some
meetings independent of management and putting
reasonable limits on unreasonable executive
compensation. Expect to see changes.
Its not clear if consumer
spendingusually the springboard in an
economic reboundcan remain at current
levels. A number of important spending
driversincluding mortgage
refinancingsappear close to being
exhausted. A few other potentially negative
factors for the U.S. equity markets are worth
mentioning. A by-product of high U.S. equity
valuations, the weak economy and the corporate
governance crisis is that foreign investors have
begun to ease the pace of their overseas
investment here. And, as a result of poor U.S.
equity returns over the past three years, pension
fund managers may decide to shift some of their
historically high weightings in stocks toward
fixed income.
In short the U.S. equity
markets face significant challenges.
Nevertheless, just as moments of market euphoria
are generally bad times to deploy capital
(investors were beating down the doors to invest
in technology in early 2000), moments of extreme
pessimism are generally good times to invest. As
the level of pessimism rises, we may be on the
verge of one of those opportunities. It is in
such times that clients need CPA investment
advisers the most. CPAs in turn, can use the bear
market to increase their market share by
persuading potential clients that this is not the
time to go it alone.
| MANAGED ACCOUNTS IN
THE LIMELIGHT |
Individually managed, or
separate, accounts are the new
must-haves for high-net-worth individuals.
Cerulli Associates, a Boston research firm,
estimates managed accounts are a $795 billion
marketplace that has grown 32% annually over the
past five years; more than 70% of it is invested
by the big five wirehousesSalomon Smith
Barney, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, UBS
PaineWeber and Prudential. The Money Management
Institutea Washington, D.C., research
organizationreports that total assets in
managed accounts are projected to grow to almost
$3 trillion by 2011.
With a managed account, the
client owns each of the securities, stocks and
bonds purchased on his or her behalf. Because the
investor owns the securities directly, the
actions of other investors (purchases and sales)
have no impact on the client. This makes
effective tax management and the ability to
undertake planning strategies among the biggest
advantages of separate accounts. There also is a
trend today toward diversification of money
managers. This means CPAs might recommend the
client use a different manager for each specific
asset allocation niche such as large cap growth
stocks, foreign stocks and bonds.
The value of the clients
portfolio is a key influence in determining
whether CPAs should recommend a separate account
manager. Some advisers use a rule of $1 million
as the cutoff for helping clients use separate
account managers; yet for others the cutoff is
much lower. There are many reasons for investors
to use outside investment managers including
these: The client asks for individual stocks and
bonds to carry out the asset allocation, but the
adviser doesnt handle individual
securities; the adviser refers all implementation
to others; and the client requests a separate
money manager. Assuming the CPA can find a
manager willing to handle the amount the client
wants to invest, lower account minimums may
apply. 
PHYLLIS J. BERNSTEIN, CPA/PFS,
is president of Phyllis Bernstein Consulting in
New York City. She previously served as director
of the AICPA personal financial planning
division. Her e-mail address is Phyllis@pbconsults.com.
| Get
Real! Managing the
expectations clients have for their
investments is crucial if CPAs are to
have successful adviser-client
relationships. This is particularly
challenging in a time of uncertain
financial markets. How to help clients
have realistic attitudes about their
investments is the focus of a new book, Managing
Client Expectations, coauthored by
Robert Doyle, CPA/ PFS of Tampa, Florida,
and Phyllis Bernstein, CPA/PFS of New
York City. The following provides a look
at the guidance included in the book.
Many accounting firms have found the
market for financial advisory services
elusive. At one time, CPAs heralded
financial planning or investment advising
as the bright spot in their firms
futures. They enthusiastically attended
seminars, purchased software, drew up
business plans and waited for clients to
call. Many of those CPAs firms have
had second thoughts and, today, dismiss
the business as a passing fad.
CPAs may find themselves asking, Can
financial advising be professionally
rewarding and profitable? Indeed it can!
It can revitalize a CPA practice. There
are practical and proven ways to add
financial advisory services to a CPA
practice.
What do clients really want? Many
times they seek a financial planner to
solve a (perceived) problem in their
financial lives. Historically, the
problem often was tax-related, but today
issues arise concerning the education of
children, retirement, estate planning or
risk management. Clients real needs
may differ from their perceived ones. The
CPAs most difficult job is to help
clients differentiate between the two.
Effective problem solving requires the
adviser to guide a client in defining his
or her goals and objectives. But a
husband and wife might have vastly
different views on what those should be.
This difference may create considerable
stress on the couples relationship
if the adviser does not handle it
properly. Often the most important role
the CPA can play as financial adviser is
to help the client develop realistic
goals and to articulate them clearly.
Once goals are on the table, the CPA and
the client can implement strategies to
achieve them.
One of the most critical tasks in the
financial planning process is helping
clients prioritize their needs. This
requires interpersonal skills, as well as
good listening and interviewing
techniques. Questionnaires are available
(the book includes a sample) that require
the client to choose from among several
alternatives, providing the CPA with
insight into his or her needs and wants.
The CPA then discusses the choices and
has the client and the clients
spouse or partner compare which are most
important. One exercise that often is
eye-opening is to ask the clients to
write three long-range and three
short-range goals and rank some other
common financial goals. Again, the CPA
should share the sometimes surprising
results with each partner.
Hearing the client is vitaland
difficultfor many advisers. To
diagnose problems the adviser must be a
good listener. It is a mistake to start
by telling a client what his or
her goals should be. Instead, the CPA
should ask questions, write down the
clients answers word for word and,
then, repeat those answers aloud. This
helps the client know what the adviser
heard and allows him or her time to
correct any misunderstandings.
| Managing Client Expectations
is available from the AICPA order
department at 1-800-777-7077. Ask
for product number 056512 (member
price $47; nonmember price
$58.75). |
|
|