| EDUCATION/PROFESSIONAL
ISSUES |
| |
| CPAs can add the spark. |
Jump-Starting
Financial Literacy
BY STANLEY
H. BREITBARD
| EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY |
IN TODAYS COMPLEX
FINANCIAL WORLD, Americans more
than ever need training to help them cope
with debt, saving, retirement planning
and similar concerns. The Jump$tart
Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy
is a nonprofit organization dedicated to
raising the level of financial knowledge
throughout the United States. SINCE SAVING AND SPENDING
HABITS FORM EARLY, the best way
to help Americans solve their financial
problems seems to be with education
starting as early as kindergarten and
lasting through 12th grade. Jump$tart
believes schools are the place to get the
job done.
IN ASSOCIATION WITH TOP
EDUCATORS AND ECONOMISTS, Jump$tart
has established benchmarks for financial
literacy in grades 4, 8 and 12. For
example, in grade 4 students learn that
people can get income by earning wages
and salaries or by receiving monetary
gifts. In grade 8 they learn about rent
and interest and by grade 12 they
understand that income relates to the
decisions they make about jobs, careers
and education.
JUMP$TART GIVES CPAs THE
OPPORTUNITY TO USE THEIR
expertise to help improve Americans
financial survival skills. They can do
this by joining an existing coalition
state board, by helping organize a
chapter in the 20 states without one or
by becoming involved in an organization
such as Junior Achievement that gives
CPAs opportunities to teach young people
about business.
THE CONTRIBUTIONS CPAs MAKE
TO THE FINANCIAL literacy cause
can have a significant impact on young
people by improving their chances to find
jobs, buy homes, educate their children
and retire comfortably.
|
| STANLEY H. BREITBARD, CPA/PFS,
is chair of the California Jump$tart
Coalition. He was national director of
personal financial services at
PricewaterhouseCoopers until his
retirement. His e-mail address is bbard@earthlink.net. |
| |
|
t a time when the financial
world is becoming more complex, education
to help consumers cope is woefully
lacking. American households carry
significant credit card debt, personal
bankruptcies are on the rise, savings
rates are declining and workers mismanage
the defined contribution plans they they
need for retirement. One organization
working to remedy this situation is the
nonprofit Jump$tart Coalition for
Personal Financial Literacy, an umbrella
organization for corporations, government
agencies, foundations and others
dedicated to improving financial literacy
throughout the United States. Jump$tart
provides accountants a unique opportunity
to contribute their knowledge and
leadership skills to make a difference.
CPAs regularly see the results of poor
financial education when they counsel
clients who have made bad business and
investment decisions. The coalition
focuses the resources of organizations
and individuals dedicated to raising the
level of financial literacy, giving CPAs
an opportunity to leverage their
volunteer efforts. This article describes
Jump$tarts work and explains how
accountants can become a part of this
critical effort to improve financial
literacy in the United States.
|
| Strategies
must be developed to overcome the
education deficiencies that all
too many of our young people
have. Just as the marketplace has
responded to an increased demand
for conceptual job skills by
increasing the range of education
options available to individuals,
efforts to provide consumers with
information and training about
financial matters throughout
their lives must also be
expanded. Alan
Greenspan, April 2003 address to
Jump$tart Coalition.
|
|
FINANCIAL STATE OF THE UNION
The absence of
personal finance education can take an enormous
toll. Large numbers of people are in financial
distress or unable to achieve their goals. Here
are some shocking facts: Some 40% of Americans
live beyond their means. Average credit card debt
per household rose to $8,562 in 2002 from $2,985
in 1990. More than half of American workers
between the ages of 45 and 54 did not have any
kind of retirement account in 1998.
Financial
ABCs
A survey showed many high
school students scored poorly on their
knowledge of money and business. Those
who used a credit card had even lower
scores and those who felt very sure
about their money skills demonstrated
less expertise than the ones who felt
somewhat sure. Average scores on the
national Jump$tart survey declined to
50.2% in 2002 from 57.3% in 1997.
|
Approximately 51% of students
surveyed said a bank certificate of
deposit is not protected by the federal
government. About a third said retirement
income from a company is called Social
Security.
Half believed
earnings from savings accounts are not
taxed by the government.
|
| Source: Financial
Literacy: A Growing Problem, Lewis
Mandell, PhD, Jump$tart Coalition for
Personal Financial Literacy, 2002. |
Spending and saving
habits form early. American teenagers spend more
than $172 billion a year. One in three 18- and
19-year-olds carries a credit card. College
freshmen get an average of eight credit card
offers their first week of school. University
administrators report they lose more students to
credit card debt than they lose to academic
failure.
The best way to attack the
problem seems to be with education, beginning as
soon as kindergarten and lasting through 12th
grade. What can kindergartners and first-graders
learn? Plenty. They see their parents at the ATM
getting cash and using plastic cards to pay for
groceries, clothing and other items every day.
Its not too early to introduce five- and
six-year-olds to the concepts of money and banks.
| Exhibit
1:
Sample Survey Test Questions |
| The Jump$tart Coalition
asked the following questions to test
high school students financial
knowledge. 1. Maria has applied for a
credit card. She is an 18-year-old high
school graduate with few valuable
possessions and no credit history. If
Maria is granted a credit card, which of
the following is the most likely way the
credit card company will reduce its risk?
a) It
will charge Maria twice the finance
charge rate it charges older
cardholders.
b) It will require Maria to have both
parents cosign for the card.
c) It will make Marias parents
pledge their home to repay Marias
credit card debt.
d) It will start Maria out with a
small line of credit to see how she
handles the account.
2. Adam
must borrow $10,000 to complete his
college education. Which of the following
would not be likely to reduce the finance
charge rate?
a) If
he went to a state college rather
than a private college.
b) If his parents took out an
additional mortgage on their house
for the loan.
c) If the loan was insured by the
federal government.
d) If his parents cosigned the loan.
3. Ron and
Molly are the same age. At age 25 Molly
began saving $2,000 a year while Ron
saved nothing. At age 50, Ron realized he
needed money for retirement and started
saving $4,000 per year while Molly kept
saving her $2,000. Now they are both 75
years old. Who has the most money in his
or her retirement account?
a)
They would each have the same amount
because they put away exactly the
same.
b) Ron, because he saved more each
year.
c) Molly, because she has put away
more money.
d) Molly, because her money has grown
for a longer time at compound
interest.
To see the
correct answers, the complete test and
how the students answered the questions,
go to www.jumpstart.org/upload/surveyresultsapril2002.doc..
|
Children need to learn
financial survival skills, and schools are the
best place to get the job done. Why is it better
to teach young people in school classrooms? Why
not help parents teach their own children? The
answer is we should be doing both. But the best
starting point is in school because most parents
themselves are poorly informed about personal
finance issues and frequently make bad role
models. Even financially savvy parents find it
difficult to talk to their kids about money.
Many organizations are
attempting to solve the financial literacy
problem. The Jump$tart Coalition brings them
together. The coalition unites 140 constituent
groups such as the NASDAQ Education Foundation,
Merrill Lynch, Bank of America, Junior
Achievement, the Federal Trade Commission, the
National Council on Economic Education and the
National Education Association. The
coalitions objective is to encourage the
teaching of personal finance in all grades.
| Jump$tart also creates public
awareness on the need for financial
education. Toward that end the
organization surveys the depth of high
school students financial knowledge
and publicizes the results. Its 2002 poll
(its third biennial survey) reached more
than 4,000 high school seniors in 179
schools across the United States. (See exhibit
1, above, for
some sample questions.) Participating
students answered 31 multiple-choice test
questions on saving, investing, spending,
taxes, retirement, insurance, credit use,
inflation and budgeting; 68% flunked the
test. This represents a huge increase
from the 59% who failed in 2000 and the
44% who did so in 1997. These results
show a dramatic need for formal financial
education of young people. |
| This
year the California Society of
CPAs is launching a financial
literacy initiative. The CPA
profession is at the heart of
sound financial decision making,
and our members take this
responsibility very seriously.
Teaching California residents
sound financial practices is just
one more way we achieve our goal
of protecting the public while
rebuilding its trust. Steven
Wimmers, CPA, chair,
California Society of CPAs.
|
|
The national
coalitionin association with top educators
and economistshas established standards and
benchmarks for financial literacy at grades 4, 8
and 12. The 26 standards define income, money
management, spending and credit and saving and
investing skills these target ages should master.
For instance
In grade 4 students
are taught that people can get income by
earning wages and salaries or by
receiving monetary gifts from others. In grade 8 students
learn that people also can earn income
from rent and interest.
In grade 12 students develop
an understanding that peoples
income reflects choices they make about
jobs and careers, education and skill
development.
Jump$tart provides a
clearinghouse of materials on personal
financial education, much of which is
free to anyone at www.jumpstartclearinghouse.org. The repository contains a
variety of books, pamphlets, workbooks
and interactive games and videos to help
children learn about money. The coalition
also puts these vast resources and depth
of expertise to use educating policy
makers. Proposed state legislation to add
some form of personal finance education
to public school curricula jumped 300% in
2002.
|
| Exhibit
2:
State Jump$tart Coalition
Efforts |
| Heres
a sampling of what some
state coalitions are
doing: California.
Teaches personal finance
to teachers; holds
semiannual member
meetings; educates and
informs state politicians
and other policy makers;
and is creating a
Web-based link of
personal finance issues
to California math
standards.
Georgia.
Sponsors Georgia
Saves, which
encourages lower-income
Georgians to start
savings plans.
Iowa.
Holds teacher training
conferences; and partners
with business, labor and
community-based
organizations to provide
personal finance
information.
Mississippi.
Conducts Money
Matters seminars;
and succeeded in getting
the states governor
to proclaim April 2003
Financial Literacy
for Youth Month.
New
Hampshire.
Holds annual MoneySmarts
teachers
conference; and created a
student advisory
committee.
Wisconsin.
Holds annual Institute of
Financial and Economic
Education for teacher
training; and holds money
conferences with programs
for children and parents.
|
|
|
Jump$tart has supported
the formation of 30 state coalitions. They
operate autonomously but exist for the same
reason as the national organizationto
promote personal finance education in schools.
The state groups in some ways mirror the national
organization, with representatives from the state
affiliates of national groups and businesses.
State Jump$tart coalitions create projects and
programs tailored to the special circumstances of
their regions. (Exhibit 2,
above, shows some of the state programs).
CASE
STUDY
Michael Eisenberg,
CPA/PFS, principal of Michael M.
Eisenberg Accountancy Corp. in West Los
Angeles, finds Jump$tart a perfect way to
contribute his unique skills to the
betterment of the community. In his
practice Eisenberg provides financial and
estate planning, taxation and consulting
services to individuals and businesses.
He first heard about Jump$tart at
meetings of the California Society of
CPAs personal financial planning
committee.Today Eisenberg participates
with Jump$tart in several roles: He is on
the board of directors of the California
coalition, instructs teachers in
financial education and works to inform
policy makers of the need to raise the
level of financial literacy. It
feels good to use my professional
expertise to help society solve some of
its major problems. And, he says,
his Jump$tart experience has made him a
more effective financial adviser because
he has learned that he needs to educate
his clients on basic financial concepts.
Eisenberg was recently appointed chair
of a new state society committee charged
with improving the personal financial
knowledge of Californians, part of the
societys initiative to increase
financial literacy. He says the committee
will be able to move more quickly by
working closely with Jump$tart instead of
creating programs from scratch.
California Jump$tart created the
Financial Smarts for Teachers
program to help educators with their own
financial lives. Eisenberg found his
experience teaching in the pilot program
worthwhile because, he says: I
helped the teachers become more
comfortable with financial issues. I
loved the experience of getting up in
front of 60 strangers and helping them
with concepts they knew nothing about.
|
CPAs NEEDED
CPAs have a long
tradition of service to nonprofit organizations.
Jump$tart gives them the opportunity to be
involved in something that relates directly to
their professional expertise. Financially savvy
consumers mean greater demand for accounting and
tax services. Promoting fiscal responsibility
also is good public relations for CPAs, firms and
the profession. And last but not least, teaching
people financial survival skills promotes
positive social change. The case study tells the story of one CPAs
involvement with Jump$tart.
State Jump$tart coalitions
offer many ways to participate: CPAs can provide
leadership by joining an existing state board or
by helping organize coalitions in the 20 states
without them; they can instruct teachers in one
of the many state-sponsored programs; and they
can help raise money and get in-kind donations
for the various coalition programs.
| CPA Mitchell Freedman, principal
of Mitchell Freedman Accountancy Corp. in
Sherman Oaks, California, participates in
all aspects of the states Jump$tart
coalition. Freedman helped organize the
coalition, serves as treasurer and member
of the board of directors, raises
donations and conducts teacher workshops. There are many opportunities for
CPAs to participate in personal finance
education. As a coalition Jump$tart
partners with other organizations that
have similar goals. Two are particularly
suitable for CPA involvement. The
National Council on Economic Education
and its state affiliates train teachers
to include personal financial skills in
their classroom lessons. Junior
Achievement uses volunteers to teach
business and financial concepts with the
cooperation of educators. See Practical
Tips on How CPAs Can Help at left for information
on how to contact and join these
organizations.
|
|
Here are
some ways CPAs can get involved
in helping to raise financial
literacy:
Join a
state Jump$tart coalition board.
Click on your states
information at www.jumpstart.org/states.cfm and
contact the groups leader.
Help
organize Jump$tart in a state
without a coalition. Contact info@jumpstartcoalition.org for
more information.
Join the
board of a state affiliate of the
National Council on Economic
Education. Check out www.ncee.net/network/directory.php.
Volunteer
for classroom teaching. Contact
your local Junior Achievement by
using the directory at www.ja.org/near/near_map.asp.
Check the
descriptions many coalition
member organizations have written
of their need for volunteers,
funding and in-kind services.
These profiles are archived at www.jumpstart.org/ff.htm.
|
|
SPARKING SUCCESS
By joining forces
with the Jump$tart Coalition and its partner
organizations, CPAs can help make a difference in
personal finance education. Teaching young people
basic financial survival skills improves the
chances they will be able to find jobs, save
money, buy homes, educate their children and
retire comfortably. Some will go even further and
succeed beyond their own dreams. 
|
AICPA
Efforts to Improve Financial Literacy
The
AICPA and the AICPA Foundation have long been
committed to educating Americans about the
importance of managing their finances. In the
past year alone, the Institute reached out to
many audiencesfrom students to women
investorsand provided them with information
to make sound tax and financial planning
decisions. In the coming year the AICPA will
bring these efforts together to underscore the
CPAs role as protector of the public
interest in teaching Americans of all ages how to
save, invest and spend money wisely. Teaching Students and
Educators
One way to educate young
Americans about money management is to teach them
about the CPA profession. Several years ago the
AICPA introduced the CPA Information Package
(iPACK), a collection that includes a video,
teachers education handbook and student
career guides. The 15-minute Takin
Care of Business video features five
successful young CPAs pursuing various career
paths. The education handbook contains 15 lesson
plans with objectives and teaching procedures,
student learning activities and solution sets. It
covers financial statement analysis, budgeting
and forecasting, cost-benefit analysis, writing a
business plan, ethics and the time value of
money. These lessons show students the importance
of understanding financial concepts and how they
relate to real-world situations. For more
information on the iPACK, go to www.cpa2biz.com/CS2000/Products/CPA2BIZ/CPA+iPACK.htm?cs_catalog=CPA2Biz.
The AICPA is also reaching students by
educating their teachers about personal finances.
Last year the AICPA Foundation provided funding
for Financial Smarts for Teachers, a
program California Jump$tart created to help
instructors understand their own financial lives
(see Case Study).
Two new television programs funded by the
AICPA Foundation focus on teaching middle and
high school students about personal finance and
the accounting profession. Geared toward junior
high school students, Pennywise teaches basic
money management concepts such as the history of
money, checking and savings accounts, ATMs and
budgeting. Business Building Blocks,
aimed at early high school students, provides
information on accounting principles such as
financial planning, budgeting and forecasting.
Both programs aired on PBS YOU in the summer of
2003. The foundation is considering other
distribution channels.
Already in its second year, the AICPA student
recruitment campaign has attracted more than
80,000 high school and college students
interested in the CPA profession. The campaigns
Web site, www.startheregoplaces.com,
features games to help students understand the
important role CPAs play in the success of
business. The site is introducing new scenarios
that allow students to practice managing money in
several business contexts.
Investing With
Knowledge
Forty-five million Americans have
more than $1.8 trillion in 401(k) plans. How can
they trust their money is being handled wisely?
Last year the AICPA provided technical review for
a handbook for CPAs and other financial managers,
Prudent Investment Practices: A Handbook for
Investment Fiduciaries, developed by the
Foundation for Fiduciary Studies. It identifies
27 essential practices anyone who has legal
responsibility for managing another persons
money should follow. The handbook references the
appropriate code sections, regulations and laws
to help users map out prudent investment and risk
management strategies. CPAs can order the
handbook at www.ffstudies.org.
Managing Finances
for Today and Tomorrow
For the second year in a row, the
AICPA and Money magazine have sponsored
Womens Financial Health Week, reaching an
estimated 80 million consumers through print,
television and radio coverage. Some 13,000 women
participated in the program in January 2003 by
visiting the official Web site and chatting
online with a Money senior editor and a
group of CPA personal financial specialists.
Women also took part in a financial comfort quiz
that offered personalized recommendations to
strengthen their budgeting skills.
For more than 15 years, the AICPA has written
articles to help consumers across America learn
how to understand their finances. The Institutes
money management series covers personal finance
and small business topics such as saving for
college, tax planning, getting out of debt,
preparing for retirement and incorporating a
business. The AICPA also creates public service
announcements and distributes them to state CPA
societies, which place them in community and
regional newspapers and on local radio stations.
Disaster planning. No
one ever expects to be affected by a catastrophe.
Unfortunately, each year, thousands of Americans
are. To help them recover from the financial
devastation of disaster, the AICPA and the
National Endowment for Financial Education
(NEFE), with support from the AICPA Foundation,
jointly developed a disaster recovery guide.
Offered free of charge by local American Red
Cross chapters, it guides people through each
stage of financial recovery. Already, more than
83,000 copies have been distributed. During
Septembers Hurricane Isabel, the AICPA
reached out to state CPA societies to help them
work with Red Cross chapters in their areas to
provide financial services to victims of the
disaster.
Cheryl Gravis Reynolds,
AICPA communications division, New York City
|
|